Skip to main content

in reply to ILikeCats

Yup, just walk away... or answer 'no' since smart folks don't always say 'yes'
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

Stupid people always say no. There are no rules given for what smart people say. One could answer no to the question and the stupid people rule may not be applicable.
This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to jaaake

Also, "Stupid people always say 'No'" is an incorrect statement. Only a Sith deals in absolutes!
in reply to dream_weasel

All !do is do not (!do); all do is do. [law of non-contradiction]. All try = do or !do [succeeds or fails, proven by observation]

Therefore, no try != Not (do or !do)

Therefore try is a useless term / there is no distinct "try" that is neither do nor do not.

One must do or do not; there is no try.

Quod Erat Demonstrandum

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to ℛ𝒶𝓋ℯ𝓃

This is true only in hindsight though. You will always have done or not done even if you always set out to "do". From this perspective it makes "don't try" a little fatalistic, no?
in reply to dream_weasel

Valid, but I do believe you're overthinking a forced star wars pun...
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

Man, I have two competing takes on this…

The statement “stupid people always say no” doesn’t prevent other classifications of people from saying no as well. Therefore someone saying “no” doesn’t give you any information on whether or not they are stupid.


And

All humans are obviously stupid, lol
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

First of all, where's the proof for the assertation that stupid people answer no? Secondly, how do you operationalise stupid? And finally, is the best person to adjudicate whether a given person is stupid really themself?
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

You can always just say no, since the condition is "always say no".
This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

That doesn't mean smart people can't say "no".

Just because I'm saying "no", it doesn't mean I am stupid!

I mean, I am stupid. But that's not because I'm saying "no"!

in reply to marcos

Exactly. The fallacy of undistributed middle is strong with this OP...

All stupid people are no-sayers. (DU) You are a no-sayer. (DU) Therefore you are a stupid person. (DU) AAA syllogism - invalid due to above fallacy.

"The middle term must be distributed at least once."

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
in reply to ℛ𝒶𝓋ℯ𝓃

The fallacy of undistributed middle is strong with this OP…


I do think that's his joke.

in reply to marcos

Although it does mean that stupid people never say yes, so this is dumb to start with.
in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

"no" =/= "No"

For a bunch of programers, I can't believe you all missed that.

in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

I accidentally deleted a service in prod yesterday

so, yes

in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

someone else could, thankfully

(after ignoring my frantic teams messages for the longest hour of my life)

in reply to Anders Rytter Hansen

Depends if I'm the one that's always lying or the one always telling the truth.